Review: Hilberry’s ‘Misanthrope’ is a rhymed riot

Lawrence B. Johnson / Special to The Detroit News

The original article may be found here.

It’s not so much that the peevish fellow in Molière’s The Misanthrope can’t abide people. What he can’t stand is society’s standard operating procedure: the pretension, the hypocrisy, the affectation and the double-dealing.

Molière was poking fun at mid-17th century Parisian society, and yet…well, suffice it to say the acerbic wit of The Misanthrope still hits home more than four centuries later in what continues to pass for civilized society. Why this send-up of manners has never lost its charm is plainly to have been seen and savored in the Hilberry Theatre production that opened Friday night.

The Misanthrope is the ultimate ensemble play, written entirely in rhymed couplets for nine actors who most not only deliver their lines like natural speech but often break into each other’s thoughts — all the while preserving the poetry’s rhythm and the dialogue’s fluency.

Andrew Papa as Alceste and Vanessa Sawson as Celimene. Photo credit: Nikki Allen

It’s a tour de force right down the line, from Molière’s brilliant original to Timothy Mooney’s flavorful English adaptation to the spunky performances by the Hilberry company and director Jesse Merz.

The gist of the play is that Alceste, a sober young man who disdains the two-faced nature of social politesse, is hopelessly smitten by Célimène, a society demoiselle who is the epitome of caprice. Thus by turns Alceste sighs with a lover’s adoration one moment only to scold the flitting Célimène the next.

Even as our ambivalent hero resists the moderating council of his good friend Philante, he also must deal with his posturing rival Oronte and fend off the gorgeous but calculating Arsinoé, who has her sights fixed on Alceste.

It would be farce if it weren’t so plausibly realistic, and this elegantly styled and handsomely decorated production stays right on Molière’s fine satirical line.

As Alceste, Andrew Papa offers a reasonable man who wants nothing more than to hear honesty from his companions. In short, tell it like it is. If you speak disparagingly of someone behind his back, don’t smile and praise and clasp the hand of that person in his presence. But when put to that test, Papa’s Alceste finds it’s impossible not to be rude.

The trial instance comes when Oronte — the prancing, scraping Alan Ball — implores Alceste to hear a sonnet he has written and to confer his honest opinion. What follows is something between an operatic duet and a vaudeville routine as Papa’s Alceste turns himself inside out trying not to dodge calling Oronte’s drivel by its right name. Ball’s hapless poet slowly gets the drift, and the whole delicate dance blows up in disastrous candor.

A similar catty square-off finds Vanessa Sawson’s pert, flirty and ever-equivocating Célimène in an escalating fusillade of insults with Lorelei Sturm’s acid-tongued Arsinoé. As their flying couplets become slings and arrows, you barely breathe lest you miss some fine abusive point.

Viewing these dustups from the sidelines, as adviser and occasional referee, stands Dave Toomey’s calm, rational, pragmatic Philinte. And adding exotic spice to it all are Jordan Whalen and Edmund Alyn Jones as two over-the-top fops who see life itself as a costume drama.

Speaking of costumes, John D. Woodland dresses the actors with eye-popping flair. And for that matter, Michael Wilkki’s Baroque set, with its curves and feathers, is fun to take in even before the play begins.

Lawrence B. Johnson is a cultural writer and critic.

3 thoughts on “Review: Hilberry’s ‘Misanthrope’ is a rhymed riot

  1. Enjoyed the play very much. The costuming and sets were phenomenal. Two things bothered me, however: the costume for Vanessa wasn’t flattering for her bustline. The effort to bulge her out didn’t work too well; it looked just tight with one breast bigger than the other. Also, fully understanding the appropriateness of Alceste’s character not being made up, a little makeup would have helped the face of Andrew not look like he just forgot to put his makeup on!.

    Love the Hilberry!

  2. Pingback: The Misanthrope Lobby Video « The Hilberry Theatre

  3. Pingback: Photos of The Misanthrope in production « The Hilberry Theatre

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s